How would you handle this situation?
A student repeatedly tries to get out of class or stay home when they know challenging work is coming up. They might ask to leave the room, complain of not feeling well, or completely avoid starting their assignments. Today, the student left the class when the teacher was providing instructions for a new project, and the student returned while the rest of the class was starting the project.
Most of us would attempt to address the behavior and keep the student on task; we might try to clarify to the student why the work is important, lay out the consequences, and try to get the student to start.
The Dialog
Our response and the interaction with the student might look something like this:
Teacher: “I noticed you asked to go to the nurse’s office right as we started the new assignment. I know the work seems challenging, but leaving the room to avoid it isn’t the right way to handle things.”
Student: “I really did have a stomachache, I wasn’t just trying to skip class.”
Teacher: “I understand your stomach hurt, but it seems like this happens often when we start a hard project. I just need you to stay at your desk and give the assignment a try.”
Student: “I can’t try it, the work is stupid and it doesn’t make any sense to me.”
Teacher: “I hear you do not like this assignment. I think if you looked closely at the directions on the board, you’d find it not so hard and that it fits in with what you need to learn in this class. How about taking a moment now and read through all the instructions.”
Student: “Reading the instructions isn’t going to help. I don’t care about them. Just give me a zero, because I’m not doing it.”
Teacher: “I really don’t want to give you a zero. If you get a zero on this project, it is going to bring down your grade for the entire semester.”
Student: “Whatever. I don’t care if my grade drops. It doesn’t matter to me.”
Teacher: “It will matter to you if you fail the class and have to repeat it next year while all your friends move on to the next grade.”
Student: “That’s completely unfair. You can’t hold me back just because I don’t want to do this one project.”
Teacher: “It’s not about this one assignment, it’s all the times you haven’t completed work. That’s not about being unfair, that’s just how grading works. If you don’t complete the required work, there are serious consequences.”
Student: “Fine, but I don’t even know how to do the first part of it anyway.”
Teacher: “I can understand why you feel lost since you missed the verbal instructions while you were at the nurse’s office. Let’s just focus on taking the first step; right now, you need to open your textbook and just get as much done as you can before the bell rings.”
Student: “I can’t read the whole chapter before the bell rings, that’s way too much.”
Teacher: “Just do your best to start right now, please. If you keep arguing instead of working, my next step will be to call your parents to discuss why your work isn’t getting done.”
Student: “Okay. Whatever.”
While we were well-meaning and definitely used empathy, it’s pretty obvious that our words fell flat. There wasn’t going to be any change in the student’s behavior.
How could we do better?
We used this interaction as the basis for a discussion in the MindShifting Practice Lab: what MindShifting practices could we use to improve the outcome of this interaction. Here are the suggestions.
1. Supporting Students Through Challenging Work
Treat avoidance as a signal for support.
Example: “Sometimes new assignments can feel tough—want to try the first part together?”
Why this works:
Avoidance is often driven by overwhelm or fear of failure. Reducing perceived threat helps the brain shift out of fight/flight and back into a learning state.
2. Balancing Expectations with Psychological Safety
Maintain expectations but lower pressure in the moment.
Example: “Let’s not worry about grades right now—let’s just get started.” or “I know you are feeling a lot of pressure, let’s take a minute and talk about something else. When is your next track meet?”
Why this works:
High pressure increases stress (distress), which reduces cognitive capacity. Lowering stakes restores access to problem-solving and engagement.
3. Using Curiosity to Understand Student Experience
Ask open-ended questions.
Examples: “What part feels confusing?” / “What’s making this hard to start?”
Why this works:
Curiosity shifts the interaction from judgment to exploration, which builds trust and surfaces root causes (skill gaps, confusion, anxiety).
Note the counter example in the dialog “but leaving the room to avoid it isn’t the right way to handle things.” Yes/but ends up cutting off conversations rather than opening them up.
4. Breaking Tasks into Manageable Steps
Chunk tasks into small actions.
Example: “Let’s just read the first sentence together.”
Why this works:
The brain handles limited steps at once. Small wins reduce overwhelm and create momentum, especially for students with executive function challenges.
5. Using Neutral, Non-Accusatory Language
State observations without judgment.
Example: “I noticed you went to the nurse when we started.”
Why this works:
Judgment triggers defensiveness. Neutral language reduces perceived threat and keeps the student open to dialogue. This is a core concept of Nonviolent Conversation.
6. Strengthening Emotional Connection
Acknowledge feelings.
Example: “It sounds like this feels frustrating.”
Why this works:
Feeling understood reduces emotional intensity. When emotions are regulated, students can re-engage cognitively.
7. Connecting Work to Positive Goals
Link tasks to the student’s goals.
Example: “This will help you move on to next year—let’s make it manageable.”
Why this works:
Positive framing activates intrinsic motivation. People are more engaged when actions align with their own goals rather than avoiding punishment.
8. Incorporating Strength-Based Feedback
Highlight what the student is doing well.
Example: “I’m glad you came back—that shows effort.”
Why this works:
Recognition builds confidence and rapport. It also shifts identity from “I can’t” to “I’m someone who can try,” which supports persistence.
9. Applying a Clear Communication Framework (NVC)
Use: observation → feeling → need → request.
Example: “I noticed you left… I’m concerned… I want to support you… would you try the first step with me?”
Why this works:
This structure reduces ambiguity and blame while making expectations clear and collaborative, increasing the likelihood of cooperation.
Overall Takeaway
These approaches work because they reduce threat, increase clarity, and build connection—three conditions that help shift a student from resistance into engagement. The key shift is from directing to partnering—using small steps, curiosity, and structured language to help the student feel capable, understood, and willing to engage.
These are some of the core tenets in the MindShifting: Conflict and Collaboration book. If you want to lead similar discussions, here is a free download.



Leave a Reply